Measuring and controlling apparatus



July 4, 1939. J F, LUHRs 2,165,182

MEASURING AND CONTROLLING APPARATUS Filed Sept. 11, 1937 2 Sheets-Sheet 1 Inventor FIG. 2 JOHN F LUHRS Gttomeg July 4, 1939. J. F. LUHRS MEASURING AND CONTROLLING APPARATUS Filed Sept. 11, 1937 2 SheetsSheet 2 Zhwentor JOHN F. LUHRS attorney Patented July 4, 1939 2,165,182

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE MEASURING AND CONTROLLING APPARATUS John F. Luhrs, Cleveland Heights, Ohio, assignor to Bailey Meter Company, a corporation of Delaware Application September 11, 1937, Serial No. 163,447 22 Claims. (01. 235-81) This invention relates to apparatus for measthe dependent variable. It will be apparent, uring and/or controlling the ratio between two however, that either or neither fluid may be variables which may be for example, pressures, controlled in conformance with the particular temperatures, rates of flow, electromotive forces conditions pertinent to any given application,

or any other physical, chemical or electrical conor that one fluid may be controlled indirectly, 5 dition or quantity. In any particular instance as by heating, cooling, or by varying the rate the variables may be the same, that is they may of application of an agent, or agents, producing both be pressures for example, or they may be or maintaining the flow of fluid. unlike one being a pressure and the other a It is, of course, evident that in many cases temperature. The invention isequally applicable the control will be unnecessary and the appa- 10 to the determination of the ratio between two ratus hereinafter described utilized merely to exabstract quantities, such as two numbers or hibit the ratio existing between two independent mathematical functions, or between an arbitrary variables. In other cases it may be desirable function or constant and a variable, as will be to utilize the apparatus merely to control a rate apparent from the description to follow: or flow of one fluid to maintain a predetermined 15 In accordance with my invention a member ratio between the two fluids and the exhibiting. is displaced from an initial position in accordapparatus may be dispensed with. ance with the magnitude of each variable, and The rate of flow of fluid through the conduit the ratio between the displacement of the mem- I is measured by a rate of flow meter generally bers determined. indicated at I sensitive to the difierential pro- 20 Further in accordance with my invention peduced by a primary element herein shown as an riodic electric impulses of a time length propororiflce 8. The meter I is illustrated as being tional to the magnitude of each variable are of the type described in U. S. Patent 1,064,748 established and the measuring and/or controldated June 17, 1913, to J. W. Ledoux. Therein ling apparatus actuated in accordance with the the dlfierential pressure established by the ori- 25 difference in time length of said impulses. fice 8 is impressed across a liquid sealed bell 9 In the drawings: having walls of material thickness and so shaped Fig. 1 illustrates diagrammatically one specific that the vertical displacement of the bell from embodiment of my invention. an initial position is directly proportional to the Fig. 2 illustrates diagrammatically a modified rate of flow of fluid and bears a non-linear 30 form of my invention as shown in Fig. 1. functional relation to the differential pressure. Fig. 3 illustrates diagrammatically a further Angularly positioned by the bell a about a embodiment of my invention. spindle i0 is a drive arm ll pivotally connected Fig. 4 illustrates diagrammatically a further to a fulcrumed lever l2. The arrangement is modified iorm of my invention. such that as the flow through the conduit l in- 35 Referring to Fig. 1, I have therein shown my creases, the lever 12 is positioned in a counterinvention specifically applied to the determinaclockwise direction in direct proportion thereto. tion and control of the ratio of the rate of flow The rate of fiow through the conduit 2 is of a first fluid passing through a conduit l in measured by a meter generally indicated at 13 th d rection of the arrow, to the rate of flow (similar to the meter 1) and having a liquid 40 of a second fluid passing thro g a co u 2 sealed bell l4 arranged to position an arcuate in the direction of the arrow. The actual ratio slotted drive arm 15 about a spindle l6. As the ex between the rates of 110W 0f e fi st flow through the conduit 2 increases, the drive and second fluids is eco d d y an index 3 0 arm I5 is positioned in a counterclockwise dia chart 4 rotated by a suitable clock mechanism rection. 45

(not shown). The ratio may also be indicated In general, my invention contemplates estaby the index 3 in OOODeIatiOH with 8 uitably lishing a first series of periodic electric impulses graduated scale 5. proportional in time length to the rate of flow The rate of flow of the first fluid throu through the conduit 1, a second series of electhe conduit I may b controlled by a valve means tric impulses proportional in time length to the 50 B to maintain substantially constant the ratio rate of flow through the conduit 2, and varying between the two rates of flow. Thus in the emthe proportionality between the second series of bodiment shown, the second fluid (flowing impulses and the rate of flow through the conthrough the conduit 2) may be considered as duit 2 to maintain the impulses of the first and the independent variable and the first fluid as second series of equal time durations. To vary the proportionality between the second series oi impulses and the rate of flow through the conduit 2 I vary the eilfective length 01' the slotted drive arm I I. and the eflective length of the drive arm is then a measure oi the ratio between the rates oi. flow. as will be apparent from the description to follow.

To periodically establish electric impulses having a time length corresponding to the rate of flow oi fluid through the conduit I I show a synchronous motor I1 energized by a suitable source of alternating current I3 and rotating a substantially heart-shaped cam II. The cam ll periodically reciprocates a follower 23 carrying a contact 2|.

Normally carried by the lever I2 is one end of a contact member 22, the other end of which is pivotally supported at 23. her 22 is a contact 24. Once each revolution of the cam I8 the contact 2I engages the contact 24 lifting the contact member 22 from the lever I2 for an increment 01' time depending upon the position of the lever I2, or inierentially. .depending upon the rate of flow oi fluid through the conduit I. As shown, the duration of the engagement of contacts 2| and 24 will vary inversely with the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I. It will be apparent, however, that any suitable mechanical arrangement for originating the electric impulses varying directly (or inversely) as the rate 01' flow of fluid may be employed.

To establish periodic electric impulses of a time duration corresponding to the rate of flow through the conduit 2 I provide a synchronous motor 25 energized from the source I8 and driving a cam 28 similar to the cam II. The cam 23 periodically reciprocates a contact member 21 into engagement with a contact 28 carried by a lever 28 pivoted at 38.

Normally the lever 28 is supported by a fulcrumed lever 3i positioned through a link- 32 by the drive arm I5. As the flow through the conduit 2 increases, the lever 28 is positioned in a counterclockwise direction, thereby decreasing the time duration of the engagement of contacts 21 and 28 during each revolution of the cam 23. That is to say, that as described with reference to the contacts 2| and 24, the contacts 21 and 28 are in engagement for a time length varying inversely as the rate of flow through the conduit 2.

The cams l8 and 28 are rotated in phase so that the position of contact 21 at all times corresponds with the position of contact 2I. Engagement of contacts 21-23 will therefore occur simultaneously with engagement of contacts 2I-24 if the rate of flow through the conduit 2 is equal to that through the conduit I and they will also disengage simultaneously. However, it the rate of flow through the conduit 2 is greater than that through the conduit I, the contacts 21-28 will engage after and disengage prior to contacts 2I-24. Conversely if the rate of flow through the conduit I is greater than that through the conduit 2 then the contacts 2I-24 will engage after and disengage prior to contacts 21-28. It will be apparent that the ditference in time length of the electric impulses established through engagement of contacts 2I-24 and 21-28 will correspond to the dinerence in the rates oi flow between the conduits and 2.

Contacts 2I-24 control a winding 33 oi a self-starting synchronous motor 34 having a sec- Carried by the memaromas ond winding 35 controlled by the contacts 21-28. Closure of contacts 2l-24 serves to energize the winding 33, thereby tending to cause the motor 34 to rotate in one direction. Closure of contacts 21-28 serves to energize the winding 38, thereby tending to cause the motor 34 to rotate in opposite direction. During the increments of time when windings 33 and 35 are simultaneously energized on deenergized, the motor 34 does not rotate in either direction.

The motor 34 is provided with a self-contained gear reduction and serves to position a cam 33 against which the index 3 bears. Likewise positioned by the motor 34 is an arm 31 pivotally connected to the link 32 through a member 38.

When the electric impulses established through closure of contacts 2I-24 and 21-28 are of equal time duration the motor 34 is not urged to rotation and index 3 and arm 31 remain stationary. Ii, however, the time duration of the impulse'caused by closure of contacts 2I-24 is greater than that caused through closure of contacts 21-28 the motor 34 rotates to position the index 3 relative to chart 4 and scale 5 and simultaneously to position the arm 31 to vary the eflective length of the drive arm I5. Periodic operation of the motor 34 will continue until contacts 21-28 are again brought into engagement for the same increment of time as contacts 2I-24, when again the motor 34 will remain stationary until there is a further change in the rate of flow of fluid through the conduits I or 2.

The cam 38, as will be readily appreciated by those skilled in the art, may be given any de-- sired shape to correct for any non-linear functional relation which may exist between changes in the effective length 01' the drive arm I5 and changes in ratio between the rates of flow through the conduits I and 2. Through the agency of the cam 33 therefore, equal changes in ratio between the rates of flow of fluid will effect equal changes in the position of the index 3.

The valve 8 is shown arranged to be actuated by a motor diagrammatically indicated at 48 and having opposed windings 4I and 42. The windin; 4| is energized through closure of contacts 21-28 whereas the winding 42 is energized through closure of the contacts 2I-24. Energization of winding 4| serves to position the valve 3 in one direction and energization of the winding 42 in opposite direction. The valve 6 will accordingly be positioned periodically in proportion to changes in the ratio between the rates of flow of fluid through the conduits I and 2 and in a direction to prevent changes in the ratio. That is to say assuming a change in ratio by an increase in the rate of flow through the conduit 2, then the valve 6 will be periodically positioned in an opening direction to increase the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I to restore the original ratio between the rates oi. flow of the fluids.

I show connected in the common wire from the motor a switch 43 and in the common wire from the motor 34 a similar switch 44. If it is desired that the apparatus shown in Fig. 1 be used to exhibit the magnitude of the ratio only, then the switch 43 may be thrown to the open position as shown in dotted line, and thereafter the valve 6 will remain stationary. Conversely the apparatus may be utilized to control only by throwing the switch 44 to open position. Thereafter the link 32 "will not be positioned relative to the drive arm I5,

U so that the motor 48 will periodically be positioned tomaintain a predetermined ratio between the rates of flow through the conduits I and 2 corresponding to the then existing length of the drive arm I6. For example, assuming that the rate of flow through the conduit 2 remains constant, but that the rate of flow through the conduit I increases, then periodically thereafter the motor 46 will be positioned for an increment of time proportional to the change in the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I until the predetermined ratio is established. By positioning the link 32 relative to the drive arm I6 the apparatus may be made to maintain any-desired ratio between the rates of flow of fluid through the conduits I and 2.

The embodiment of my invention shown in Fig. 1 may be utilized regardless of the distance by which the conduits I and 2 are separated, for between the meter 1 responsive to the rate of flow through the conduit I and the meter I3 responsive to the rate of flow through the conduit 2 merely electrical conductors are utilized. In Fig. 2 I show a modified form of my invention, which may be conveniently employed when the conduits I and 2 lie adjacent each other, making it feasible to employ mechanical linkage between the meters 1 and I3. For the sake of clarity I have shown the embodiment of my invention illustrated by Fig. 2 in isometric projection with certain parts distorted as to size, as will be obvious to those skilled in the art.

In the embodiment of my invention shown in Fig. 2 the meter I3 angularly positions a lever 56 about a shaft 5i. Likewise supported by the shaft 5I is an arm 52 having a laterally extending projection 53 normally resting on the lever 50.

The meter 1 angularly positions an arcuately slotted arm I5 similar to the arm I5 of Fig. 1. A lever 54 is positioned about the shaft 5I by the arm I5 through a depending link 54A. Normally resting on the lever 54 is a laterally extending projection 55 of an arm 56 pivoted about the shaft 5 I. As the rates of flow through the conduits I and 2 vary, the levers 50 and 54 are positioned in consonance therewith. Specifically, as the rates of flow increase the levers 50 and 54 are positioned in a counterclockwise direction about the shaft 5I and as the flows decrease they are positioned in a clockwise direction.

Energized by a suitable source 51 is a synchronous motor 58 driving a substantially uniform rise cam 59. Periodically reciprocated by the cam 59 is a follower 60 pivotally supported by the shaft 5| and carrying contacts 6| and 62 connected through a wire 63 with the source 51.

The arm 52 carries a contact 63 and the arm 56 a contact 64. Once each revolution of the cam 59 contact 62 engages contact 63 and contact 6| engages contact 64. Closure of contacts 62-63 serves to energize a winding 65 of a motor 66. Closure of contacts 6I-64 serves to energize an opposed winding 61 of the motor 66. Energization of the winding 65 serves to rotate the motor 66 in one direction and energization of winding 61 serves to rotate the motor 66 in opposite direction. When windings 65 and 61 are simultaneously energized or deenergized the motor 66 is not urged to rotation.

The motor 66 serves to position the index 3 and simultaneously and in consonance therewith to position the link 54A relative to the drive arm l5 as explained with reference to link 32 and arm I5 of Fig. 1.

Assuming that the apparatus disclosed in Fig. 2 is in equilibrium, then contacts 62-63 and 6I-64 will engage and disengage simultaneously, so that the motor 66 will not be urged to rotationin either direction. Assuming now that there is an increase in the rate of flow through the conduit I then contacts 62-63 will engage prior to and disengage after contacts 6I-64. During the increments 01' time when contacts 62-63 only are engaged, the motor 66 will move in a direction to restore simultaneous engagement and disengagement of contacts 6I-64 with contacts 62-63. Simultaneously with such operation the index 3 will be positioned relative to the chart 4 and scale 5 to record and indicate the ratio and change in ratio.

Conversely upon a decrease in the rate of flow through the conduit I the contacts 6I-64 will engage prior to and disengage after contacts 62-63, thereby causing through sole energization of winding 61 rotation of motor 66 in opposite direction, again positioning the link 64A relative to the drive arm I6 to restore simultaneous engagement and disengagement of contacts 6 I-64 and 62-63.

As shown and as explained with reference to Fig. l, the motor 66 is arranged to actuate the index 3 through a suitably shaped cam 68, so that while the index 3 is positioned in proportion to changes in the effective length of drive arm I5, direct proportionality does not exist, so that movements of the index 3 may be made directly proportional to changes in the ratio between the rates of flow of fluid through the conduits I and 2 regardless of the existing functional relation between changes in effective length of drive arm I5 and changes in ratio. 1

The embodiment of my invention shown in Fig. 2 may be utilized to control the rate of flow of fluid through one of the conduits to maintain a predetermined ratio between the rates of flow therein. In Fig. 2 I show apparatus similar to that disclosed in Fig. l for controlling the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I. Arranged to be energized by contacts 6I-64 and 62-63 is the motor having opposed windings H and 42. As shown, the winding 42 is arranged to be energized by closure of contacts 62-63 and the winding 4I through the closure of contacts 6 I-64.

In the neutral connectors tothe motors 66 and 40 are shown switches 44 and 43 respectively, so that the apparatus disclosed in Fig. 2 may be used to merely exhibit the ratio between the rates of flow of fluid through the conduits I and 2, to simultaneously exhibit and control the ratio between the rates of flow of fluid or to merely control the ratio between the rates of flow of fluid.

In Fig. 3 I show a further embodiment of my invention wherein I periodically establish electric impulses of a time length varying in accordance with changes in the ratio between the rates of fluid flow (i. e. a plurality of variables) and then vary the effective length of a drive arm or member until said periodic electric impulses are again made equal to electric impulses of a predetermined time length. Referring to Fig. 3 I therein show the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I measured by the meter 1 and the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit 2 measured by the meter I3. The meter 1 positions a slotted arcuate drive arm 16 in accordance with changes in the rate of flow through the conduit I. The meter I3 positions a drive arm H in accordance with changes in the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit 2. The slotted arcuate drive arm 16 arm 1I jointly position a differential beam 12.

Movements of the arm 16 are transmitted to and drive I the beam 12 through a link 18 movable relative to the slotted drive arm 10. So long as the flows through the conduits I and 2 remain equal or in predetermined ratio to each other, then the mid point 18 of the beam 12 will remain in a predetermined position. If the flow through the conduit I increases above that through the conduit 2, then the mid point 18 will move upward an amount proportional to the difference. Conversely if the flow through the conduit 2 increases above that through the conduit I, then the mid point 18 will be positioned downwardly from the position shown an amount proportional to the difference.

Pivotally connected to the mid point 18 is a member 15 having a laterally extending foot 16 normally supporting one end of a pivoted lever 11 carrying a contact 18. The contact 18 will accordingly be positioned about the pivot support of the lever 11 in accordance with, changes in the difference between the rates of flow through the conduits I and 2.

Arranged to be periodically reciprocate-d at a substantially uniform time rate by a cam 18 is a pivoted lever carrying a contact 8|. Accordingly, contacts 8I and 18 will periodically engage for a time increment depending upon the vertical position of the mid point 18. Also carried by the lever 80 is a contact 82 arranged to engage a contact 83 carried by a lever 88 normally held against an adjustable stop 85 by a suitable counterweight 88. Once during each revolution of the cam 19, contact 82 will engage contact 83 for a predetermined increment of time. which may be varied by adjustment of the stop 85.

The contacts 188I control a winding 81 of a self-starting synchronous motor 88, the opposed winding 88 of which is controlled by contacts 82-43. Positioned through a cam 80 by the motor 88 is the index 3 and the motor also positions an arm 9i which controls the position of the link 13 in the arcuate slot in drive arm 10.

If contacts 18-8I and 82-83 engage for the same increment of time during each revolution of the cam 18, then the motor 88 remains stationary. However, upon a change in flow through the conduits I or 2 the duration of closure of contacts 188I will vary, thereby causing the motor 88 to be positioned in one direction or another. Such positioning of the motor 88 will result in a corresponding positioning of the index 3, and of link 13 in the slotted drive arm 10. Periodic operation of the motor 88 will thus occur until the duration of closure of contacts 188I again corresponds to the duration of closure of contacts 82-. This status will occur when the mid point 14 has been re stored to a predetermined position through the movement of the link 13 along the drive arm 10. The effective length of the drive arm 10 is then a measure of the ratio 01' the rates of flow fluid through the conduits I and 2 and the index 3 moving in consonance with the link 18 is therefore positioned in accordance with the ratio. As described with reference to Figs. 1 and 2 the cam 80 may be given any desired shape so that movements of the index 3 will be directly proportional to changes in ratio or in any desired relation thereto.

The rate of flow of fluid through either the conduits I and 2 may be controlled as explained with reference to Figs. 1 and 2. In the embodiment shown in Fig. 3 I show the flow of fluid through the conduit I adapted to be 'With the switch 88 controlled by a valve 82 actuated by a motor 88 having opposed windings 84 and 85. Contacts 82--88 serve to energize the winding 88 whereas the winding 88 is energized by closure of contacts 188I. In the'common connector to the motor 88 is a switch 88 and in the common connector to the motor 88 is a similar switch 81. With switches 88 and 81 closed motors 88 and 88 are operated simultaneously in parallel. opened the motor 98 will remain stationary and the apparatus shown merely record and indicate the ratio existing between the rates of flow of fluids in the conduits I and 2. With the switch 81 open and the switch 88 closed, then the apparatus will merely regulate the rate 01' flow of fluid through the conduit I to maintain a predetermined ratio with respect to the flow through conduit 2.

It the flow through the conduit 2 is maintained constant at some predetermined value by any suitable means herein shown as a manually actuated valve 88, then the apparatus disclosed in Fig. 3 will operate to maintain the rate of flow of fluid through the conduit I in predetermined ratio thereto or to maintain the rate of flow at a constant magnitude. Accordingly, as will be apparent to those familiar with the art, the apparatus I have shown in Fig. 3 may be utilized to maintain a rate of flow of fluid or other variable at any predetermined desired value.

In Fig. 4 I show an embodiment of my invention somewhat similar to that shown in Fig. 3 but employing a modified arrangement for varying the positioning of the differential beam 12 by the meter 1. Therein the meter 1 positions a drive arm 88, which is pivotally connected by a link 88 to a horizontal lever I00. Movements of the lever I00 are transmitted to the differential beam 12 through a link ml.

The lever I00 is angularly positioned about a movable fulcrum I02 carried by a stationary support I03 and slidable vertically in a slotted link I04 angularly positioned by the motor 88.

Upon a change in the rate of flow through either the conduits I or 2, indicating a change in the ratio between the rates of flow, the slotted drive arm I 08 is angularly positioned by the motor 88, thereby moving the fulcrum I02 along the support I03 and varying the vertical position of the link IOI and accordingly the midpoint 18 for a given rate of flow through the conduit I. Such periodic movements of the motor 88 and resulting movement of the fulcrum I02 will continue until the midpoint 14 has been restored to the predetermined vertical position, as explained with reference to Fig. 3.

The index 3 is moved relative to the chart 4 and scale 5 by the motor 88 through a suitably shaped cam I05 so that movement thereof will be directly proportional to changes in ratio rather than directly proportional to changes in position of the fulcrum I02.

It is apparent that in any of the embodiments of my invention shown, any desired range in ratios may be measured. For example, referring to Fig. l, the arcuate slot in drive arm I5 may be of such design that a change in ratio of from 0.5 to 1.5 is required to position the link 32 from one end to the other. By changing the size of the orifice 8 relative to the size of the orifice in conduit 2 so that a greater or lesser flow is required to position the meter 1 through its travel, the range in ratios through which my device is operative, may be easily changed to meet the particular conditions pertinent to any particular case. As will be readily appreciated by those familiar with the art, in the event that from time to time material changes in the basic ratio between the flows through conduits I and 2 occur, the orifice 8 may be made adjustable but upon such changes in the basic ratio the size of the orifice 8 may be varied to maintain the apparatus within its operative limits.

While I have described certain specific embodiments of my invention, it will be apparent that further modifications may be made without departing from its scope and that therefore such embodiments of my invention as I have chosen to describe should be taken as merely illustrative and not as limiting.

What I claim as new, and desire to secure by Letters Patent of the United States, is:-

1. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising a lever angularly displaced about a fulcrum from an initial position in accordance with the magnitude of each variable, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time length proportional to the displacement of a predetermined point on one of said levers from the initial position, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time length proportional to the displacement of a selected point on the other of saidlevers, and means under the joint control of said impulses for varying the point selected on said last named lever until said impulses are of identical length, whereby the radial distance of said finally selected point from the fulcrum is a measure of the ratio of said variables.

2. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising a drive arm angularly positioned about a center in accordance with changes in the magnitude of one variable, means for periodically establishing electric impulses in accordance with the displacement of a given point on said drive arm from an initial position, a variable length drive arm angularly positioned from an initial position in accordance with changes in the magnitude of the second variable, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time length proportional to the displacement of said variable length drive arm from the initial position, and means under the control of said impulses for varying the length of said variable length drive arm until said impulses are of identical time length when the length of said variable length drive arm is a measure of the ratio between said variables.

3. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising a first lever angularly positioned about a center in accordance with the magnitude of one variable, a second lever angularly positioned about a center in accordance with the magnitude of the other of said variables, a motor having opposed windings, means for periodically energizing one of said windings for increments of time proportional to the displacement of said first lever, means for periodically energizing the opposed winding for increments of time proportional to the displacement of said second named lever, and means under the control of said motor for varying the length of said second named lever until said windings are energized for equal increments of time whereby the length of said second named lever is a measure of the ratio between said variables.

4. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising a first lever angularly positioned about a center in accordance with the magnitude of one variable, a second lever angularly positioned about a center in accordance with the magnitude of the other of said variables, means for periodically establishing electric impulses in accordance with the product of the magnitude of the first variable multiplied by the length of said first lever, means for establishing electric impulses in accordance with the products of the magnitude of the other variable multiplied by the length of said second lever, and means for varying the length of said second lever under the control of said impulses to maintain said impulses identical whereby the length of said second drive arm is a measure of the ratio between said variables.

5. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising means for periodically establishing electrical impulses of a time length bearing a functional relation to one of said variables, means for periodically establishing elec-, tric impulses of a time length bearing a functional relation to the other of said variables, means under the control of said impulses for varying the functional relation between the time length of said second named impulses and the magnitude of said other of said variables, and indicating means positioned by said last named means.

6. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising means for periodically establishing electric impulses 01' a time duration bearing a predetermined ratio to the magnitude of one of said variables, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time duration bearing a predetermined ratio to the magnitude of the other of said variables, means under the control of said electric impulses for varying the ratio between the time lengths of said second named impulses to the other of said variables to maintain said impulses of similar lengths, and indicating means positioned by said last named means.

7. In an apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables, in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time duration proportional to one of said variables, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a predetermined duration, and means for varying the proportionality between the magnitude of said one of said variables and said first named impulses to maintain said first and second impulses of identical time duration.

8. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising, a motor having opposed windings, means for periodically energizing one of said windings for increments of time proportional to one of said variables, means for periodically energizing the other of said windings for increments of time proportional to the other of said variables, and means for varying the proportionality between the time duration of said first named impulses and variable to maintain the time duration of said first and second named impulses equal.

9. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables comprising, an electric motor having opposed windings, means periodically for time increments proportional to the magnitude of one of said variables energizing one of said windings, means periodically for increments of time proportional to the magnitude of the other of said variables energizing the other of said windings, and means under the control of said motor for varying the time length of the periodic energizations established by said first named means.

10. In apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables, in combination, a member jointly positioned by said variables, means for varying the positioning of said member by one of said variables, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of constant time lengths, means for establishing electrical impulses of a time length proportional to the position of a. predetermined point on said beam, and means under the control of said impulses for actuating said first named means to maintain said second named impulses equal in time length to said first named impulses.

11. In apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables, in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time duration proportional to changes in said ratio, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a constant time length, means under the joint control of said impulses for varying the time length of said first named impulses to maintain the time length of said first named impulses in desired proportionality to said second named impulses.

12. In apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables, in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses having a predetermined time length when a given ratio exists between said variables, and a difi'erent time length upon departure of said variables from the given ratio, means for establishing electric impulses of a. time length corresponding to said impulses of predetermined lengths, an electric motor having opposed windings under the Joint control of said impulses for controlling said first named means to maintain said impulses at the predetermined value, and indicating means under the control of said motor.

13. In apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables, in combination, a first member movable in proportion to one of said variables, a second member movable in proportion to the other of said variables, a differential link connecting said members for establishing electric impulses of a time length proportional to the position of a point on said first member, means for establishing electric impulses of a predetermined time length corresponding to the time length of said first named impulses when said point is in predetermined position, and means for varying the ratio of movements oi said first named member in response to changes in said one of said variables under the joint control of said first and second named'impulses.

14. Ratio determining apparatus comprising in combination, means for establishing periodic electric impulses of a time duration proportional in magnitude to a first variable, means for establishing periodical electric impulses of a time duration proportional to the magnitude of a second variable, and means under the joint control of said electric impulses for maintaining said impulses of equal time duration.

15. Apparatus for maintaining a constant ratio between two variables comprising in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a time length variable in dependence upon changes in the ratio between said variables, means for establishing periodic electric impulses of a time length corresponding with the desired ratio between said variables, and means under the joint control of said impulses for varying one of said variables to maintain the time duration of said electric impulses in predetermined ratio.

16'. In an apparatus for determining the ratio between two variables. in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a predetermined time duration, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a duration variable from said first named impulses in accordance with changes in said ratio, and means under the joint control of said impuls'es adapted to alter the duration of said second named impulses so as to restore said impulses to equality.

17. In an apparatus for determining the ratio between two quantities, in combination, means for periodically establishing two impulses having a diflerence in time duration corresponding to changes in ratio between said quantities, means under the joint control of said impulses for varying the proportion between one of said quantities and one 01' said impulses to restore said impulses to equal time duration whereby said change in proportion is a measure of the change in ratio between said quantities.

18. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two quantities, comprising in combination, means for periodically establishing electric impulses of a predetermined time duration, means for periodically establishing electric impulses variable in time duration from the duration of said first named impulses in accordance with changes in the ratio between said quantities, and means jointly responsive to said impulses for varying the proportionality between said second named impulses and one or said quantities to restore said impulses to equal time duration, whereby said change in proportionalities becomes a measure 01' the change in ratio.

19. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two quantities, comprising, means for pcriodically establishing electric impulses 01' a predetermined time duration, means for periodically establishing electricimpulses variable in time duration in accordance with changes in the ratio between said quantities, and means jointly responsive to said impulses for varying the time duration of said last named impulses to maintain siaid first and second impulses of equal time dura- 20. Apparatus for determining the ratio between two quantities comprising, a motor having opposed windings, means for periodically energizing one of said windings for predetermined increments of time, means for energizing the other of said windings for increments 01' time proportional to at least one of said quantities, and means sotuated by said motor for varying the proportionality between said second named impulses and one of said quantities to maintain said impulses equal in time duration.

21. A torque amplifying mechanism for positioning an output shaft in correspondence with the magnitude oi. a variable, comprising in combination, a motor having opposed windings which when simultaneously energized do not urge said motor to rotation, but when either is energized alone urges the motor to rotation in opposite direction each from the other, an electric circuit for each of said windings, an output shaft driven by said motor, a first contact member positioned in correspondence with the magnitude of the variable and connected in circuit with one of said windings, a second contact member connected in circuit with the other of said windings and operatively connected to said output shaft and positioned in correspondence with the position thereof, a cam, means for rotating said cam through a series of successive cycles, a circuit closer reciprocated by said cam and arranged to engage each of said contact members for a portion of each' cycle corresponding to the position thereof whereby said motor is rotated during each cycle an amount corresponding to the difference in time duration of engagement of said circuit closer with said contact members and said second contact member is positioned in a sense to restore correspondence of position with said first contact member.

22. In a torque amplifying mechanism for positioning an output shaft in correspondence with the magnitude of a variable, in combination, a shaft, a first member pivotally mounted on said shaft and angularly positioned about said shaft in correspondence with changes in the magnitude of a variable, a motor, an output shaft driven by said motor, a winding for said motor which when energized urges said motor to rotation in predetermined direction. an opposed winding for said motor which when energized urges said motor to rotation in opposite direction and when both said windings are energized said motor is not urged to rotation, a second member pivotally mounted on saidshaft and angularly positioned about said shaft in correspondence with changes in the position of said output shaft, a first contact arm pivotally mounted on said shaft and normally resting on said first member, a second contact arm pivotally mounted on said shaft and normally resting on said second member, a circuit closer pivotally mounted on said shaft, means for reciprocating said circuit closer through a series of successive cycles, said circuit closer arranged to reciprocate said firstv and second contact arms through a portion of each cycle determined by the position of said first and second members respectively, an electric circuit for said first winding including said first contact arm and said circuit closer whereby said first winding is energized for the portion of each cycle during which said first contact arm is reciprocated by said circuit closer, an electric circuit for said opposed winding including said second contact arm and said circuit closer whereby said opposed winding is energized for the portion of each cycle during which said second contact arm is reciprocated by said circuit closer whereby said motor is urged to rotation proportional to the difference in time duration of the energization of said windings and said second member is positioned to maintain the time duration of the engagement of said circuit closer with said first and second contact arms equal.

JOHN F. LUHRS. 

